When a business owner hears their banker say ‘I need reviewed financial statements’ or their lawyer asks about a ‘Notice to Reader,’ it can be easy to nod and hope it becomes clear later. Understanding the difference between the three levels of financial statement engagements available to Canadian businesses is not just helpful — it can save you money and prevent you from getting the wrong product for your needs.

Here is a plain-English explanation of compilation engagements (formerly known as Notice to Reader), review engagements, and audited financial statements — and how to determine which one your Edmonton or St. Albert business actually requires.

First: A Terminology Update

You may have heard accountants use the term Notice to Reader (NTR) for years. Under the updated Canadian Standard on Related Services 4200 (CSRS 4200), which became effective for periods ending on or after December 14, 2021, the Notice to Reader format was replaced by the Compilation Engagement Report. Many accountants and clients still use the terms interchangeably in conversation, but technically, the Notice to Reader no longer exists under current Canadian professional standards. If your accountant refers to a compilation engagement, a compilation report, or an NTR, they are referring to the same product.

Level 1: Compilation Engagement (formerly Notice to Reader)

A compilation engagement is the most basic level of financial statement service. Under CSRS 4200, a CPA compiles financial information provided entirely by management into a structured financial statement format. The accountant does not verify the underlying data, test internal controls, or express any opinion on whether the statements are accurate. The compilation report explicitly disclaims any assurance.

What it is used for: corporate tax return preparation (the T2 requires financial information through the General Index of Financial Information, or GIFI), internal management purposes, straightforward bank financing requests where the lender does not require a higher level of assurance, and shareholder reporting for owner-managed businesses.

Cost: Compilation engagements are the least expensive of the three options. Cost varies depending on business size and complexity.

What it does not do: it does not verify that the numbers are correct, it does not provide any assurance to a third party, and it is not appropriate when a lender, investor, or regulator requires a higher level of confidence.

Level 2: Review Engagement

A review engagement involves analytical procedures and inquiries by the CPA — a deeper level of scrutiny than a compilation. The CPA reviews the financial statements for plausibility and reasonableness, asks questions about significant balances and transactions, and applies analytical techniques to identify anything that appears materially misstated. The result is limited assurance: the CPA can state that nothing has come to their attention that would indicate the statements are materially misstated.

What it is used for: bank financing where the lender requires more assurance than a compilation provides — typically for credit facilities where the lender wants moderate confidence in the financial information; situations where there are shareholders not involved in day-to-day operations who need independent confidence; and some regulatory requirements.

When do banks require reviews? As a general guideline, many lenders require reviewed financial statements for credit facilities where the level of borrowing or the complexity of the business warrants more than a compilation. Requirements vary significantly by lender and credit product. Always confirm with your specific lender what level of engagement they require before commissioning the work.

Level 3: Audit

An audit is the highest level of financial statement engagement. A CPA performs extensive substantive testing, verification of transactions, independent confirmation of balances, assessment of internal controls, and a comprehensive examination of the financial records. The result is reasonable assurance — the auditor expresses an opinion that the financial statements are, in all material respects, fairly presented in accordance with the applicable accounting framework.

What it is used for: public companies (required by securities regulations); certain regulated industries including banking, insurance, and securities dealers; not-for-profit organizations above certain revenue thresholds depending on their governing legislation; privately held corporations where lenders, investors, or co-owners require the highest level of independent assurance; and businesses with complex ownership structures or significant external financing.

Most small privately held businesses in Edmonton and St. Albert do not require an audit unless their lender, shareholder agreement, or regulatory requirements specifically mandate one.

One CPA Cannot Both Prepare and Audit

An important independence requirement: a CPA who compiles or prepares your financial statements cannot be the same CPA who audits them. Independence is a fundamental professional standard for audit and review engagements. If your business requires an audit, it must be performed by a CPA who has not been involved in preparing the underlying financial records.

How to Determine What Your Business Needs

Start with the purpose: If you are preparing financial statements primarily for tax filing and internal management, a compilation engagement is almost certainly sufficient. If your bank or lender requires something specific, ask them directly what engagement level they require before you commission the work — requirements vary by institution and credit product. If your shareholders, investors, or a regulatory body requires independent assurance, a review or audit may be necessary depending on their specific requirements.

At Nguyen Scott LLP, we prepare compilation engagements for owner-managed businesses throughout the Edmonton Metropolitan Region, and we can advise you on whether a review engagement is required for your specific circumstances. We offer a free 30-minute consultation — book at nsllp.ca/contact-us/

Nguyen Scott LLP — Chartered Professional Accountants. This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute tax or legal advice. Please consult a qualified CPA for advice specific to your situation.

Contact Us
Learn More About Notice To Reader